Who decides on teacher discipline?

Only an incomplete list of disciplined teachers is available
2009-03-28T23:00:00Z Who decides on teacher discipline?Kayla Gahagan, Journal staff Rapid City Journal
March 28, 2009 11:00 pm  • 

Teacher discipline cases in South Dakota are heard by the state Professional Teachers Practices and Standards Commission. The seven-member commission - six teachers and one parent - is appointed by the governor.

Anyone can make a complaint about a teacher, said Lisa Lomheim, a legal assistant with the Department of Education, but should complain to local school leaders first.

"Local efforts need to be exhausted," she said, including complaining to the local school board and administration.

If that has already been done and the complaint goes to the commission, it can be dismissed for a lack of information, go to a hearing or the commission can investigate and then decide to dismiss or go to a hearing.

If the case makes it to a hearing, the teacher can request it to be private, Lomheim said, which happens almost all of the time.

Based on the hearing, the commission can dismiss the complaint or file a written complaint to the Secretary of Education, requesting the teacher's certificate be revoked or suspended.

A revocation is permanent, and the only way it can be reversed is if the person is pardoned by the governor. Then, he or she can reapply and get recertified again.

"That has happened in our state - that erases the record," Lomheim said. "It doesn't happen very often."

The commission dealt with 13 cases in 2007, down from 18 in 2006.

In West River schools, eight cases have made it to the commission during the past five years. The state has about 9,000 certified teachers.

On the Web

For more on the commission, go to http://doe.sd.gov/oatq/propractices/

Teachers disciplined by state Department of Education

The list below names South Dakota educators who have been disciplined both publicly and privately for a wide variety of reasons by the state Department of Education. The disciplinary actions include reprimands, suspensions and revocations.

This version of the list, released by the National Association of State Directors of Teacher Education and Certification, was updated in 2007 and goes back 20 years. The database is made available to other state education departments, but does not provide details on why teachers were disciplined, and leaves it to states or hiring school districts to dig for more information.

The president of NASDTEC has said the list is incomplete and opposed publication of it. Repeated calls for an updated list were not returned.

Ben Ahrendt

David Barkus

Roger Bordeaux

Ronald Carlson

William Carpenter

Robert Childers

Mark Christopherson

David Cunningham

Shawn Currey

Douglas Daughters

Julie Davis

Donald Enoch

Teresa Erickson

Richard Evans

Kelly Faiman

William Falconer

Cheryl Fieber

Darrell Fincher

Kesiah Fredrick

Frank Freedman

Patrick Freidel

Jennie Frey

Patrick Gaffney

Steven Gapp

Terry Garvey

Joanne Gauer

Rani Gordon

Pamela Gough

Jerry Gravatt

Angela Grider

Jared Grosshans

Timothy Harmon

Frances Harris

Melissa Hartman

Kari Hiller

Steven Hilt

Rod Hinrichs

Gordon Hooks-Williams

Carrie Howard

Kenneth Hudson

Hank Hulst

Annette Hunter

Heather Huppler

Leo Jensen

Larry Joy

Michael Kelner

Donald Kizer

Kevin Klawonn

Joel Kline

Richard Kotrba

Dallas Krauch

Carolyn Laplante

Robert Larson

Gary Leighton

Robert Maxwell

Kathleen McGeehon

David Mills

Trevor Mischke

Carol Mitchell

Barry Monson

Richard Moose

Donald Mudloff

Duane Nelson

Bradley Oakley

James Ochsner

Larry Ogle

Marlin Olson

Michael O'Riley

Michael Pecenka

Neal Petersen

Terry Peterson

Jimmy Phifer

Stacy Pudwill

Donna Randall

Gregg Rochester

Debra Ruen

Juan Sabalier

Seth Schneider

Jerry Smith

Kenneth Stands

Edith Steger

Carey Story

David Strain

Ronald Studt

Cooper Troy

Joel Tuck

Kim Uecker

Keith Weigandt

Thomas White

Andrew Wilson

Related stories

Who decides on teacher discipline

Colleges prepare future teachers to avoid errors in judgment

Checking educator backgrounds can be difficult, misleading

Copyright 2015 Rapid City Journal. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

No Comments Posted.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick