A koi by any other name smells the same — like a carp.

Even so, a monster koi with a whitish-pink body, long, frilly fins and protruding "eyebrows" was among the hundreds of fish saved this week by the state Game, Fish & Parks Department at Memorial Pond.

As the water level was dropped in preparation for a $1.2-million construction project in and near the pond, GF&P crews determined the fish wouldn't survive for long. So they began a rescue operation that captured more than 500 fish, most of which are now swimming in new waters.

For the big koi, a member of the carp family that has captured the imagination of anglers at Memorial Pond for years, home is now the Jolly Lane Greenhouse in east Rapid City.

Things were going swimmingly for Jolly Lane partner Todd Sime on Friday afternoon after the koi delivery by GF&P.

"I put him in my outside pond, because he was too big for the inside one," Sime said. "He's a big one."

The koi was never weighed, but the fisheries crew and shoreline experts estimated it to be between 20 to 30 pounds. And it wasn't the only lunker hauled out of the waning waters of Memorial Pond on Friday morning.

There was a channel catfish estimated at 20 pounds, plus a handful of northern pike from 10 to 20 pounds each. They were part of about 150 fish taken Friday, including an assortment of smaller largemouth bass, yellow perch, black crappies and a couple of rainbow trout.

Added to the rescue total earlier in the week, which included green sunfish, rock bass, bullheads and shiners, Friday's effort brought the total number of fish removed to more than 500.

The fish rescued Friday were taken to Bear Butte Lake near Sturgis, where the big catfish and northern pike will provide trophy fishing potential and help control the overpopulating bullheads.

Other fish have gone to the GF&P pond at the Outdoor Campus-West, as well as the large aquarium of local fish inside the facility. Rough fish were killed and frozen to be used as fertilizer by GF&P.

But the biggest and most flamboyantly attired of the rough fish, the koi, deserved royal treatment, said Keith Wintersteen, an Outdoor Campus-West naturalist.

"We all looked at each other and said 'We can't kill the koi,'" he said. "We're emotionally invested in it." 

Others shared that investment. The Memorial Pond koi was likely dumped in the pond by someone who took it out of a private pond. For years it had captured attention but avoided lures and baits in the tiny reservoir near the Rushmore Plaza Civic Center.

Other trophies also attracted anglers of all ages to the pond. John Brewick, a retired Rapid City teacher, was a regular there for many years. And he came out Friday to see what he had been missing all those years.

"It's sad to see this fishery go," he said. "But I think it will be back."

That's the plan by GF&P. Regional fisheries manager Gene Galinat said he would prefer to manage the pond as a trout fishery without the complications of the general public's unauthorized stocking. The large northern pike in the lake, also likely the products of some citizen fish stocking, clearly feasted on smaller fish, including rainbow trout stocked by GF&P.

"When the water comes back up, we'll be putting in catchable rainbows. I think we could make a real quality trout fishery here," Galinat said. "I think we could keep catch rates high and make people happy. When you throw in a bunch of other species, it really complicates things."

Brewick understands that and loves to catch trout. But he also likes angling for a variety of fish and thinks young anglers do too.

"I like a diversity," he said.

The diversity of fish in the pond was initially expected to survive the construction project, but the pond turned out to be shallower than expected. And with levels drastically reduced for construction work and warmer weather coming, the outlook for the fish turned grim.

"At this level, we're expected to lose that fishery when the water warms up," Galinat said. "We're trying to get out as many fish as we can."

A GF&P fisheries crew used waders, hand-held dip nets and a compact electro-fishing pack earlier in the week to capture fish. On Friday, they used a small, flat-bottomed boat pushed with oars through shallow water churning with fish. A crew member dropped the shocking wand over the side. 

The electro-fishing wand sends a charge through the water, stunning the fish and bringing them whirling or thrashing to the surface. There they are netted and lugged to a GF&P fish truck nearby.

There could be another rescue effort next week. There were still more fish roiling the water in little pockets between thick mats of exposed vegetation Friday.

There are certain to be more bass, crappies and perch, and probably a big pike or two.

Another koi has been spotted in the pond from time to time. It is a distinctive black and white and fairly good sized.

How big might it be? Only the pond knows for now. But GF&P might find out next week.

Contact Kevin Woster at 394-8413 or kevin.woster@rapidcityjournal.com

(4) comments

AF Ret
AF Ret

Absolutely stock it as a diverse fishery. Put the Trout in the hills.Don't waste our money making it something that we don't need. Someone will stock other species eventually wasting all the effort. What better place for a Grandparent, Parent, Mentor, Big Brother or Big Sister to start memories with a child for a lifetime. But wait.... This would be a free fishery, and we all know SDGFP can't stand to lose money. Look at the Black Hills lakes. No Free Easy access for shore fishing except 385 turnout on Sheridan Lake. Talk about a captive audience. Leave Memorial Park alone. If it ain't broke, Don't fix it.


Please do not stock trout in Memorial Pond. We have enough trout fishing spots in the hills now. Look at the vast variety of fish that was currently in the pond. That was amazing. Those varied species inspired great stories and family legends. There is nothing special about catching a 10" stocked trout. If you want to stock trout, stock them in the Black Hills many many area creeks (like you did 30 years ago) where trout belong. Memorial Pond was doing just fine without the GFP's so called "management" practices.


You said it!!! My kids love to fish there because of the diversity. Trout are BORING!!! Every where you go trout trout trout. To have had such fishing diveristy and fish legends in town was great. Please don't stock with BORING trout, you can get those everywhere.


We were down there with our kids today and were very sad to see all the dead fish on the surface. We used to love taking our 10 and 14 yr olds there because of the diversity of fish when we r not able to afford the gas to go up in the hills (stockade of Sheridan for example). I hope SDGFP will rethink their decision of only stocking the pond with only Rainbows (yes they r fun to catch but so pike, bass, etc....). A person shouldn't have to drive anymore into the hills to catch the same fish when the water here (Rapid City is still the Black Hills last time I checked) can support it. I think it not only would benefit our local Economy but also our tourist as well if they knew when they came here that they could fish the same kind of fish that Stockade or Sheridan has because they would spend more at Main street Square (within walking distance) plus all the other great things our city has to offer!. It makes perfect sense to me to stock the pond with different species. Remember the movie Field of Dreams and I'm going to quote now "If u build it they will come". I'm going to say "if u stock it they will come!"

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.