New study calls for better reporting by Indian Health Service

2011-10-01T08:00:00Z New study calls for better reporting by Indian Health ServiceRuth Moon Journal staff Rapid City Journal
October 01, 2011 8:00 am  • 

When Theresa Spry's son had a grand mal seizure on a Sunday early in July and she couldn't talk with the doctor in Sioux San Hospital's emergency room, she went straight to Rapid City Regional Hospital.

Now, more than two months later, she is still trying to mediate between Sioux San and Regional to get her bill paid. She just got a letter telling her the $250 bill is overdue, even though she wrote a letter to Indian Health Service explaining why her son had to go to Regional for treatment.

"There's no reason to have to do health care this way," said Spry, who is on the board of the Sioux San Task Force, an Indian Health Service oversight board that works for better services at Sioux San.

The U.S. Government Accountability Office agrees. In a report issued last Friday, the office outlines a study of federal funding adequacy for Indian Health Service's Contract Health Services program. The contract program funds referral services when patients must seek treatment outside an Indian health service facility.

Most contract health services programs that responded to the accountability survey reported that they did not have enough money to pay for all the referral services patients required. Some contract programs continued to approve services anyway, and some worked on ways to help patients find free or low-cost health services.

Part of the reason contract health services runs out of money frequently is that Indian Health Service does not collect complete or consistent information on how many patients are referred to other hospitals and what services they are referred for, according to the report.

Both of South Dakota's senators are frustrated enough by the issue that they signed a letter to Yvette Roubideaux, director of Indian Health Service, and Kathleen Sebelius, secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, calling for a concrete plan to fix the situation.

"It seems like every year they run out of money, so all we're trying to say is, ‘Keep accurate data,'" said Sen. John Thune. "This is a fairly significant program with no apparent idea of what its true costs are or should be."

Frustration runs both ways, Thune said, and tribes are often uncertain what data to give Indian Health Service. A more accurate count of services patients needed and used will make it easier for the federal government to give the program enough money to help everyone who needs it, he said.

"It's been a point of contention for some time to try to determine what the actual need out there is," he said.

It's well-known that Contract Health Services runs out of its federally allocated funds before the end of the fiscal year in September, said Sen. Tim Johnson in an email interview. He called Indian Health Service data collection methods "erratic and insufficient."

Fred Koebrick, chief executive of Sioux San Hospital, would not comment on the study or Sioux San's referral services. In a federal response to the study, Indian Health Services agreed that its data collection methods are inconsistent and that a federal workgroup would look for technology tools to collect more accurate information without creating too much work for employees.

Inaccurate data and the resulting fund shortage have a tangible effect on local Native Americans who are denied referrals for services they need, or find out too late there's no money available, Spry said.

"The unfortunate part of this is the funding level. At this time of year they're out of money," she said. "Your services, after the fact, get denied - and it leaves us in a bind."

Contact Ruth Moon at 394-8418 or


Copyright 2015 Rapid City Journal. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(3) Comments

  1. wayawa
    Report Abuse
    wayawa - October 02, 2011 12:26 am
    This is so sad to hear when Indian people have been sent away with serious health problems because IHS has told them there is no money. I know people who can not walk without great difficulty because knee surgery is the only solution. These people have been given a pair of crutches or a walker and told that is all IHS can do due to no money. I know people who have severe back pain from vertebrae damage and pinched nerves that radiate so much pain they have trouble sitting, standing and walking. IHS gives them more pain pills and says there is no money for surgery although the MRI supports this. Heart patients are also given a bag full of meds when by-pass surgery is inevitable but again the patient is told there is no money for contract care. It is such a boost to know that our 2 Senators are aware and asking for IHS to do its job and get the data to support all they have turned away. There is a great need to reconstruct IHS services. One way is to take the money that it costs to run the IHS bureauracy and pay local medical clinics and hospitals to provide health care services to Indians. I bet there would be better health care for Indians at a much lower cost!
  2. Eggman
    Report Abuse
    Eggman - October 01, 2011 4:53 pm
    How about a "study" calling for better Health Service by Indian Health Service.
  3. badhand
    Report Abuse
    badhand - October 01, 2011 9:02 am
    They continue to fail to provide this information because there is no consequence to the hospital and the people that work there. If their jobs were terminated because of mismanagement and more competent people hired things would change rapidly.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Activate subscription button gif

Deals, Offers and Events



Fur-Ever Wild was just approved to keep wolf cubs and fox kits at a wildlife education center in Deadwood. Do you agree with the South Dakota Animal Industry Board's ruling?

View Results

Recent Blog Posts

Osu Sensei

Osu Sensei

The one thing that is constant in our job is that you meet quite a few people every day. It may be only a handful others it may range into 20 …

12 hours ago(0)



JBEEZ = JB's (adorable car)

16 hours ago(0)

Beam me up

Beam me up

Sometimes, the every-day grind of photojournalism leads to some less-than-spectacular assignments. Last week, I was sent out to Summerset to t…

May 22, 2015 1:30 pm(0)

Valley Queen disputes Otter Tail’s pricing

The state Public Utilities Commission never seems to have a dull day of late. The latest dispute to land in the laps of commissioners Chris Ne…

May 22, 2015 7:43 am(0)

Cosmetology commission gets new members

Gov. Dennis Daugaard appointed Laurie Brandner of Pierre and Crystal Carlson of Beresford to the state Cosmetology Commission. Carlson succeed…

May 21, 2015 7:57 am(0)