Life is more relaxed in Keystone these days, following the shooting of three mountain lions that had confronted dogs, strolled through yards and killed deer on city streets.

State Game, Fish & Parks Department officers killed an adult female lion and two 40-pound kittens in Keystone on the nights of May 5 and May 6 after a string of cat sightings in town over several weeks.

GF&P also killed a 2 1/2-year-old male lion at Angostura State Recreation Area near Hot Springs on May 6 because it was hanging out near a park recreational trail, watching hikers and bikers go by.

"The park ranger at Angostura observed that lion for 15 or 20 minutes, just sitting within about 20 yards of the trail watching people go by," said John Kanta, regional wildlife manager for the state Game, Fish and Parks Department in Rapid City. "Because that cat didn't leave and was exhibiting what we believed was bold behavior, we considered it a threat. It was just too close for comfort."

The lions in Keystone were causing widespread unease among locals. People in town had been talking about lion sightings and an occasional photograph of a lion for weeks. They were seen by the Ruby House Restaurant, the Big Thunder Gold Mine tourist attraction and in in yards near homes on Highway 40, which winds through town.

"There were a lot of residents getting concerned about safety, especially with the tourists coming in," Big Thunder owner Sandi McLain said. "Everybody said it was too bad they had to be shot, but you've got to consider the safety of your children and the visitors."

McLain points out that it was GF&P that made the decision to remove the lions. And Kanta said it was one he and other official delayed in hopes the female lion would take her kittens and leave town.

Keystone is a narrow community built mostly along creek bottoms squeezed between forested slopes and craggy mountains. It's perfect lion habitat, with deer and turkey in and near town for lions to hunt.

"It's not like they're walking around at the Rushmore Mall. Keystone is basically built along a road right through the middle of perfect lion habitat," Kanta said. "So we decided we would give that lion a chance to move her kittens out of there."

Instead, Kanta said, the lion kept "doing what lions do," but in situations where it became a potential hazard to humans. And when the female on Sunday made another deer kill "right in the road near the post office and the Country Store on Highway 40," Kanta said it was "two strikes and you're out."

When a resident saw two lions with a spotlight behind his house, Kanta authorized a GF&P conservation officer to respond and kill the cats. The officer managed to shoot one of the lions.

On the evening of May 6 night a GF&P trapper who specializes in lion removals came in and set up behind the house where the lions were spotted the night before. He used an infrared night scope and a muzzle-blast suppressor to kill the cats with reduced sound.

Kanta said the female lion appeared healthy, as did her kittens. He said he wished she had moved them out of town.

"I certainly don't think that lion was in town looking to eat people. She was killing deer. That's what lions do," Kanta said. "But I don't want lions walking down sidewalks and killing deer out in the street."

The Angostura lion was in some ways more of a concern because it was so intently watching people as they passed nearby, Kanta said.

"We didn't see any reason that cat was sitting there. There was no kill nearby. It was just lying there watching people," Kanta said. "It wasn't exhibiting any fear of people or showing any signs of leaving the scene. It just stayed put. This was different. It was just too bold for our liking."

GF&P records show that 12 lions determined to be threats or problems have been "removed" so far this year. Eleven of those have been killed by GF&P.

There tend to be spurts of lion activity throughout the hills, when an area might have a string of lion reports and more than one might be removed, Kanta said.

"There's no explanation for it," he said. "They just come like this."





Contact Kevin Woster at 394-8413 or

(7) comments


In my eyes, the problem with the lions coming into town, and having no fear of humans comes as a result of people feeding wildlife, deer turkeys, etc. The lions follow the deer and they learn to associate humans with food. I have seen in happen in my area. Neighbors feeding wildlife-- now there are mountain lions all over, eating pets, and killing deer and caches in people's back yards. Feeding wildlife should be made illegal in South Dakota. I am surprised that the mountain lion advocates don't pursue this issue, as I think it would benefits the lions more than any single thing!!


GF&P policy: See lion, shoot lion.

Don't suppose they'll count these 4 against next season's limit. GF&P can kill as many as they want. Just part of the ongoing eradication program dressed up as management policy. Ever wonder why the estimated number of cats never changes despite the hundreds that have been killed? Doesn't everybody working there have enough lion mounts and rugs by now?

Steve B
Steve B

All you folks advocating for relocation should talk to Don Edgar on North Pole Rd. west of Custer. About 4-5 years ago he had a lion killing his Canadian geese and finally constructed a live trap and caught the lion. Called GF&P and they came took the lion 25 miles away and released it. Two days later the cat was back killing his geese again. This time GF&P put the
lion down. Relocations are rarely successful, but they make lion huggers feel all warm and fuzzy...


I don't think killing the lions was the best choice! Its probably the easiest, but a mom and two young lions should be moved first before shot and killed. GF&P needs to think about whats best for the animals too - its not their fault humans have taken over almost of all of their natural territory! Relocate!


Matowatakpe; I strongly agree why not relocate? It sure seems to me that GF&P has been kill crazy of late. The danger of a cat attacking a person is absolutely minimal if at all. Such a ridiculous wast of some beautiful creatures that are just doing what they need to survive. There is no reason that we can't make the effort to relocate.


kittac would you want one in your back yard ? The reality of it is, one day a human will be attacked and one of the causes wil be that the cats have no fear of humans , not a good thing for them or us !!


did they even TRY to relocate these animals? they have all the equipment, and resources to have, at the very least tried to capture and release them somewhere else. mountain lions adapt very quickly, and would have been fine living in a wilder less populated area.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.